Both the Father's Rights Side and the Protective Mothers are Wrong. Families Need Mental Health Support, Not Biased Laws


Extreme conflict affects 10 to 20 percent of divorced and separating families, my family among them.  These families include those who self-identify as Parental Alienation Syndrome (PAS) survivors, protective parents, domestic violence survivors, and father’s rights advocates.  In PAS, parents experience a co-parent manipulating their children to reject a loving and previously loved parent--something more inclusively called coercive control. All of these families experience the judicial system as stacked against them. These are also the families that make multiple visits to the courtroom with accusations of physical, sexual, and psychological child abuse.  And these families tend to see different solutions to the very similar problems they face.

Parental Alienation experiencers say that their co-parents manipulate their children to reject them, but many Parental Alienation victims ally with Father's rights groups that want laws that mandate children spend fifty percent of their time with each parent as the best solution because judges don’t always rule that children should spend time with both parents. 

Fathers’ rights advocates also believe the judicial system is biased against them and feel that fathers end up with too little parenting time, which is why they advocate for fifty/fifty custody laws.

On the other hand, domestic violence victims, who are usually female, also often lose custody of and contact with their children. Many are low-income moms unable to hire therapists and attorneys to fight abusive co-parents in court. Moreover, the domestic violence perpetrators continue psychologically abusing their victims through lies and false accusations in the courtroom. Unless the domestic violence victims have had lots of therapy and support, they may be so emotionally fragile that they fall apart in the high-pressure environment of the courtroom. Judges tend to rule against people who cry or get angry in court, judging them to be emotionally unstable.  

Protective Parents, on the other hand, find their children behaving in ways indicative of child abuse. For example, a toddler girl may complain of pain in and around her vagina and show knowledge of sex no child that age should have. However, young children cannot clearly communicate this information, and without a prompt medical exam for documentation, there is often too little evidence for the court or child protective services to act. Not only are these parents unable to protect their children from abuse, but they sometimes lose custody of them too.  

So, why don’t lawmakers make better laws concerning domestic violence, child abuse, custody, and parental visitation to solve all these problems?

Because all the various victim groups are so divided that they don’t see what they have in common. All these various forms of abuse—domestic violence, physical and sexual child abuse, and Parental Alienation Syndrome—involve psychological abuse now known as coercive control.

For example, consider the controversy surrounding Parental Alienation Syndrome (PAS).  Father’s rights groups and parents experiencing parental alienation believe the syndrome is real, but protective parents’ groups call PAS junk science. The diagnosis is not found in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Revision (DSM VR) because it is not based on rigorous scientific studies but on the anecdotal observations of Dr. Richard Gardner, who was a custody evaluator. However, Dr. Gardner was also a clinical professor at Columbia University's medical school, Division of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.  

As a former wildlife biologist, I know that scientific studies of animal behavior are often inspired by anecdotal observations of biologists and animal lovers. Moreover, scientists have a hard time conducting studies without funding, so a lack of funding to study the issue may be part of the problem. Rather than dismissing Parental Alienation Syndrome as being junk science, high-conflict separating and divorced families need to be the subject of long-term, longitudinal studies along the lines of the work of Dr. Judith Wallerstein so that we may better understand what is going on in these families as well as understanding the long-term impact extreme conflict between parents has on children.

Moreover, as a mother whose former husband falsely accused me and our son of abuse and then denied me contact with our daughter for more than 18 months, I identified as a parental alienation survivor. Because my ex-husband sent me hundreds of emails filled with criticism and blame, and requesting to take our children for vacations and holidays during time that our parenting plan gave to me, I also identify as a victim of coercive control domestic violence. 

My ex-husband and his second wife also exerted coercive control over our children. My son, who chose to live with me, still feels anxious and angry whenever he remembers the abuse he suffered in his father and stepmother’s house. He developed Irritable Bowel Syndrome, which is, in part, caused by stress. His sister, who chose to live with her father after she turned 13, struggled through chronic depression, self-mutilation, multiple suicide attempts, and a mental illness common among child sex abuse survivors called Borderline Personality Disorder(BPD).  She attempted suicide two or three times and did not begin recovery until she left his house and stayed in a psychiatric care facility for almost a month. Despite obtaining court orders for family therapy and a Parenting Time Coordinator, I could not protect my children from being coercively controlled by their father and stepmother, so I also identify with protective parents.

However, while child sexual and physical abuse are felonies, coercive control is only beginning to be recognized as illegal. 

So why can’t survivors of parental alienation, domestic violence, and protective parents get together and see that they all have psychological abuse in common?

The answer is humans think tribally.

As a former wildlife biologist, I think about the adaptive aspects of human behavior. Our ancestors lived in hunter-gatherer tribes far longer than we have lived in settled towns and cities. We humans have only spread across this planet in large numbers in the last hundred years or so. Ten thousand years ago, there were so few of us humans around that we might never have met another person outside our tribe. On the other hand, we would meet far more bears, wolves, cougars, tigers, and lions than today. We depended on our tribe for protection from predators. We also depended on our tribe for food. For example, during the Stone Age, how did a mother with a baby eat and feed her newborn baby without support from her tribe? Because our ancestors depended on being part of a tribe to survive, our way of thinking evolved to reinforce our relationships with other members of our tribe.

In the modern world, we don’t depend on tribes for survival. We can have a good-paying job (hopefully), buy cars for transportation, buy food we need from stores, buy a computer and good internet connections, and really not interact with other people very much. We normally only encounter lions, tigers, bears, and wolves if we visit zoos or develop a passion for hiking and camping in the wilderness.  But due to the influence of genetics on behavior, our brains are still wired to live in a tribe, and so we divide into tribes.  These divisions are often along our way of perceiving the world around us into familiar and safe and unfamiliar and unsafe groups. 

One of the characteristics of our tribal way of thinking is confirmation bias.  This is when people filter out information that does not conform to their preconceived biases.  For example, Democrats rarely listen to Fox News because they don’t agree with the point of view expressed on Fox News.  Republicans, on the other hand, often rely on Fox News precisely because they like how the channel presents news.

Just as people sort themselves into political groups who usually reject information from sources they don’t like, father’s rights, parental alienation survivors, and protective parents often listen to arguments they agree with and don’t listen to parents with different perspectives.  

Ironically, the human instinct for tribal thinking is also the adaptation psychologically abusive parents exploit to alienate their children from their co-parent.

To cope with my involuntary separation from my daughter and to help my children cope with the psychological abuse they were enduring, I worked with therapists, including Family Systems therapists and a court-ordered Parenting Time Coordinator.  I also learned therapeutic skills such as Nonviolent Communication (NVC), self-calming skills from Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), and Compassionate Listening. These skills helped me be a better parent and co-parent. I feel that these therapeutic interventions should be automatically mandated by law for high-conflict families. Unfortunately, in order to obtain court orders for the Parenting Time Coordinator and Family Systems Therapy, I had to spend four years in mediation, arbitration, and court and more than $65,000 in attorney’s fees.  Fortunately, I prevailed, and the judge ordered my ex-husband to pay me almost $45,000 of my attorney’s fees. Unfortunately, those four years I spent on legal procedures fighting to get the right therapists in place delayed healing for my children, and the money I spent on lawyers could have paid for all the therapy we needed three or four times over.

Since I prevailed in court to regain contact with my daughter, I wanted to share with the Parental Alienation survivors how I prevailed.  

Because I was a mother who suffered false accusations of abuse and who lost contact with my daughter for 18 months after she went to live with her father, I initially identified with the parental alienation tribe. I became a member of a parental alienation discussion Facebook group. 

Unfortunately, I found that a vocal contingent advocating for fifty/fifty custody splits dominated the parental alienation discussion group.  These fifty/fifty custody advocates knew nothing about Family Systems therapy or Court-Ordered Parenting Coordinators, nor did they want to know. Although one father made the valid argument that fifty/fifty custody mandates were the only relief to the alienation of his child that he experienced, others seemed intent on silencing me. I tried to explain what happened in my family and why I believed fifty/fifty custody laws would make it hard for parents to protect their children from abuse. When I revealed that I was a child sex abuse survivor, one fifty/fifty custody advocate diagnosed me as being an alienating mother with Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD). He obviously had not read my posts thoroughly enough to know that I was the parent who experienced false accusations of abuse and who had lost my daughter to an alienating father and stepmother. Moreover, this father’s rights advocate made his diagnosis without asking me anything about my life, so he didn’t know that I had participated in more than a decade of individual, couples, and Family Systems Therapy. Nor did he know that I had a background in a variety of therapeutic skills, including NVC, DBT, and Compassionate Listening.  Moreover, DBT just happens to be the treatment for Borderline Personality Disorder.

In other words, this father’s rights advocate falsely accused me of being mentally ill and the cause of problems in my family. Parental alienation survivors, does this sound familiar? Oh, and are there any domestic violence survivors reading this blog? Has your co-parent accused you of being mentally unstable?

After this psychologically abusive and opinionated fathers’ rights Facebook poster, I encountered another Facebook poster who also harshly criticized my rejection of the fifty/fifty custody approach.  She went on and on about how fifty percent of abuse accusations are false.  After I revealed that I lost my daughter to her father after he falsely accused me of abuse, she identified herself as a lawyer who advocated for falsely accused parents. Obviously, she conducted herself online like an aggressive lawyer advocating for their client in court—repeating her point over and over and never conceding any ground. Aggressive lawyers can win for parents in court, but they leave an already wounded high-conflict family even more brutalized and wounded.

The answer to false accusations and conflict is not more conflict.

After my awful experiences with father’s rights advocates, I thought my adult son sharing his story of abuse he suffered at his father’s and stepmother’s house might persuade some of these advocates that maybe there was another side to the story. My son posted to the same Facebook group. He recounted his experiences with his father restricting his ability to use the bathroom, leaving him out of family trips and meals at restaurants, making him sleep in the same room as his stepgrandmother, who would not let him take naps, restricting his access to computers with word processing programs that he needed for schoolwork, and criticizing and blaming him for family problems and then laughing at him, interrupting him, and putting him down during therapy. Instead of listening to my son’s story and considering its implications, the fathers’ rights advocates criticized him and attacked him and blamed him as viciously as his father and stepmother had done years before.

I had enough. I was not going to subject my son and myself to any more psychological abuse.  I blocked the most aggressive fathers’ rights Facebook posters and then left the parental alienation discussion Facebook group.  My son also left the Facebook group.

Had I not met actual fathers with heart-rending stories to tell about court orders for visitation with their children that were rarely obeyed, had I not been a victim of parental alienation and false accusations of abuse myself, I would have turned against the fathers’ rights and parental alienation advocates permanently.

However, I didn’t find refuge in the protective parents’ pages on Facebook either.  When I posted that victims of abuse could help themselves by focusing on changing themselves, the moderator of the group blocked me from the group for blaming victims.  I never got to share with the group that I won my case and a substantial portion of my attorney’s fees by working with a Family Systems therapist and a Court-Ordered Parenting Time Coordinator and studying Nonviolent Communication, Dialectical Behavior Therapy, and Compassionate Listening.  Honestly, I was also annoyed when advocates repeated the statistic that only four percent of accusations of abuse are false.  As a victim of recanted false allegations of abuse, I know this statistic is misleading.  First, it is well documented that the rate of false accusations of abuse is three times higher in high-conflict divorced and separating families.  Moreover, child protective services routinely find 50 percent of the accusations of abuse they investigate “unable to determine” or “unsubstantiated.”  The 50 percent of accusations of abuse found to be “undetermined” or “unsubstantiated” does not actually mean that 50 percent of accusations are false.  It means a variety of conditions make it challenging to validate abuse. These conditions include accusations that are so old that the evidence for their validity is weak.  In addition, the abuse may not have been bad enough to do anything about.  How many of us parents have been perfect parents?  Have you never yelled at your child or your romantic partner?  Have you never criticized them or blamed them for a problem unfairly?  Have you never slapped or spanked your child without leaving a lasting mark?  Have you never felt you needed to apologize for something you did?  If you think you have never done anything to apologize for, you probably have at least some of the traits of Narcissistic Personality Disorder and are possibly abusive.  We all say and do abusive things, but our actions and words don’t rise to the level of criminal abuse unless they are frequent, prolonged, or severe.

So the truth is ambiguous and lies somewhere in the undefined space between Protective Parents and Parental Alienation victims

If we all remain entrenched in our own ideas and experiences while rejecting those of others, we will probably not be able to pass good laws to cope with abusive parents, whether they sexually or physically abuse children or merely psychologically abuse them by manipulating them into rejecting a loving and previously loved parent.

Is there anything all sides can agree on?

The one thing I see in common between parental alienation victims, protective parents, and domestic violence victims is the identification of the abusive co-parent as having Narcissistic  Personality Disorder (NPD) or Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD).

Can we then all agree that the underlying problem is mental health? The mental health of the abusive co-parent, the target co-parent, and the children are all important.

If we can agree that mental health is important, can we also agree that requiring therapy and that parents and children learn therapeutic coping and communication skills is important?  Moreover, requiring families to work with therapists can also provide additional evidence for the causes of the conflict in the family.

People who are diagnosed with either NPD or BPD often resist therapy. This resistance provides evidence to help determine whether or not serious child abuse has taken place (since most of us parents have engaged in milder abuses of our children).  But more importantly, people with Narcissistic or Borderline Personality Disorders (BPD) do sometimes embrace therapy and get better. For example, one third of BPD sufferers who embrace DBT recover from BPD in two years. Another third recover within five years, and the remaining third recover within ten years. The goal should not be that one parent gets custody of the children, and the other never sees them. The goal should be that both parents have contact and healthy relationships with all children… except in cases of gross abuse. 

Unhappy divorced families can become healthy if all parents and children embrace therapy and therapeutic coping and relationship skills.

Parents who resist therapy and learning and using therapeutic relationship and coping skills or who have committed severe abuse may only have contact with their children supervised by a Family Systems Therapist, or they may have no contact at all.  If they resolve their psychological issues through therapy, the Parenting Time Coordinator and the Family Systems Therapist can increase their parenting time.

So then, how do we overcome tribal thinking and confirmation bias so that the different sides can come together and advocate for mental health interventions to heal family relationships and protect children from abuse?

The answer once again lies in the therapeutic skills I am advocating for. One way to open someone else’s heart is to listen to them and validate their experiences, feelings, values, and wounds with compassion. 

Remember, if we win and they lose, they will still feel hurt, and the conflict will continue.  We need solutions that address the feelings and needs of all sides.

To bring all sides together.  We need details and complexity.

Social scientists have studied how people think and react to arguments about hot-button issues such as gun control—another issue where people on opposite sides remain very far apart and almost completely unable to hear each other.

When people are exposed to succinct summaries of each side of an issue, those who advocate for one side or the other become even more convinced their side is right. But when our arguments become detailed and complex, differences between different sides of passionate issues begin to break down.

Remember what happened when I told the lawyer on the parental alienation discussion Facebook group that I was falsely accused of abuse and lost contact with my daughter; she opened up to me. Unfortunately, by then, I felt so wounded that I had already shut down. I withdrew from her rather than engage in further interactions with her.

I think the best way to see all sides of this parental alienation vs. protective parents custody issue is to share stories…in detail.  Now that my children are grown, I have been traveling around my home state of Oregon talking to domestic violence advocates (mostly in the smaller counties because those in the bigger counties don't seem to think I am important enough to talk to) or standing in front of courthouses in most of Oregon's counties around the lunch hour or before the end of the day when both staff and court litigants come out of courthouses. I have met victims of abuse, victims' advocates, and litigants who felt the system does not work well or is too complex and too expensive to navigate. I even met an attorney who wondered why parents were so willing to spend $90,000 litigating child custody issues in a week-long trial. She was the attorney earning the $90,000, but she still felt frustrated by the situation.

Why not try making it mandatory for parents to learn the necessary mental health skills? Perhaps a therapist can work as a custody evaluator after meeting several times with the parents and the children. (I don't have this all figured out in a legal sense. I am just trying to suggest a shift in the process away from lawyers towards family mental health.) 

The focus of courtroom trials should remain the best interests of the children. Judges tend to do this, but if one parent has an attorney and the other doesn’t, the process is biased toward the parent with an attorney. 

I also want to hear the stories of parents, grandparents, and children who have lost family to alienating parents or domestic violence and child abuse offenders.  I also want to hear from fathers who are not able to spend much time, or any time at all, with their children. 

Hacking is so prevalent that I'm reluctant to give out my contact information. If you want to hear from me or share your ideas with me, sign in to Google and comment on this blog or check out my Facebook page: The Family Mental Health and Child Custody Act, and leave me a message there.

(c)Virginia Jones



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Clergy Abuse Won't End Until Parishioners Step Up

Louise Bauschard: A Life Dedicated to Breaking the Cycle of Abuse

Final Results of Survey on Clergy Abuse