Sentenced to ......Therapy?
The title of this piece refers to a response to an Op-Ed piece I wrote for The Oregonian newspaper against a proposed law that would criminalize false accusations of abuse. I advocated for family therapy instead of criminal prosecution because the majority of false accusations of abuse come from divorced or divorcing parents. They are a symptom of dysfunctional relationship skills rather than criminal activity. The Oregonian website published comments on my Op-Ed piece below the piece. Most comments strenuously criticized me for opposing the criminalization of false accusations.
One man commented, “Virginia Jones would sentence us to therapy.”
Truthfully, being sentenced to therapy is a good idea.
The biggest mistakes I’ve made in my life have always come when I did not follow the advice of my therapist.
I made one of these mistakes in the aftermath of the removal of a priest from my parish for sexually abusing teenage boys in 2002.
I made one of these mistakes in the aftermath of the removal of a priest from my parish for sexually abusing teenage boys in 2002.
This priest, who baptized my children and me, had a history of accusations of abuse no one in our Catholic parish knew about. Church leadership knew about these accusations but withheld that information from parishioners. So, when I allowed my son to sit in the priest's lap for 2 hours, I did not know his history. My son was on the autism spectrum and felt comfortable with very few people. I thought his liking the priest was a good sign, that he could attach to people other than his father and me and my child psychologist friend who knew precisely how to help him calm down and feel safe. I did not know the priest was probably grooming him.
Fortunately, one of the priest's survivors managed to finally get his story printed in a newspaper during the eruption of the clergy abuse scandal in 2002, and the priest was removed before he could do real damage to our family.
The accusations made by this survivor divided my parish, and attendance dropped by ⅓ within five months of the priest’s removal. Church leadership held a few forums during the first six weeks after the priest’s removal, but then talk about the priest was shut down. Church staff provided minimal information and support to most parishioners. However, many wounded and confused parishioners remained wounded and confused for years. Some left the Church. Some muddled through their confusion and pain. Some remain Catholic but left the parish. For many years, one sad, confused woman asked me about the priest whenever she saw me, simply because I had informed myself about his case and was willing to talk about him.
In my frustration with the lack of answers from Church leadership, I combed through newspaper articles on the internet and began handing out articles on the clergy abuse scandal to fellow parishioners. To say the least, Church leadership was not pleased with me. One day before Mass, I was provoked into shouting by a staff member, and another parishioner called 911 on me. An ambulance came to the street by the south door of the church to pick me up, but I was lured by staff members to the door on the north side of the church, where I was met by a policeman, who told me that I would be arrested for trespass if I ever came back to Church. Church leadership, knowing that only a small number of parishioners had actually seen my newspaper articles, told everyone that I was mentally unstable. By shouting in Church, I had confirmed my craziness. If I had consulted my therapist before shouting, he doubtlessly would have told me not to shout in church.
Fortunately for me, one of the parishioners who had read my articles was moved to request to share my side of the story before the Pastoral Council of the Church. They reacted with a modicum of compassion, but the then pastor of the parish refused to apologize to me or allow me back to the parish. Fortunately, a few months later the pastor was moved to another parish and a new, much more compassionate pastor apologized to me and invited me back to the parish.
I returned and tried again to interest other parishioners in the clergy abuse scandal. Although interest in the issue was not huge, there remained, a few years after the removal of the abusive priest, parishioners who remained hurt and confused by what had happened in our parish.
Well, anyway, in the short version of my story, a clergy abuse survivor abused by a different priest helped me restart forums on clergy abuse, but these forums were run by a moderator who was contracted by the Church.
In my frustration with the lack of answers from Church leadership, I combed through newspaper articles on the internet and began handing out articles on the clergy abuse scandal to fellow parishioners. To say the least, Church leadership was not pleased with me. One day before Mass, I was provoked into shouting by a staff member, and another parishioner called 911 on me. An ambulance came to the street by the south door of the church to pick me up, but I was lured by staff members to the door on the north side of the church, where I was met by a policeman, who told me that I would be arrested for trespass if I ever came back to Church. Church leadership, knowing that only a small number of parishioners had actually seen my newspaper articles, told everyone that I was mentally unstable. By shouting in Church, I had confirmed my craziness. If I had consulted my therapist before shouting, he doubtlessly would have told me not to shout in church.
Fortunately for me, one of the parishioners who had read my articles was moved to request to share my side of the story before the Pastoral Council of the Church. They reacted with a modicum of compassion, but the then pastor of the parish refused to apologize to me or allow me back to the parish. Fortunately, a few months later the pastor was moved to another parish and a new, much more compassionate pastor apologized to me and invited me back to the parish.
I returned and tried again to interest other parishioners in the clergy abuse scandal. Although interest in the issue was not huge, there remained, a few years after the removal of the abusive priest, parishioners who remained hurt and confused by what had happened in our parish.
Well, anyway, in the short version of my story, a clergy abuse survivor abused by a different priest helped me restart forums on clergy abuse, but these forums were run by a moderator who was contracted by the Church.
I was in therapy at the time. I knew I needed to tell two stories. The first was about how the priest groomed my son and me -- a story I still largely keep private. The second was about how badly the church treated me when I handed out newspaper articles about clergy abuse to other parishioners. Many parishioners knew the church's version of the story -- that I was mentally unstable. Few knew my version of what happened. My therapist wanted me to tell the story of others abused by this priest before I told mine because she was afraid that I wouldn’t be believed by other parishioners and would be wounded by cruel comments from other parishioners attending the forum. She felt I needed to establish a pattern of behavior by this priest and by Church leadership so that, by the time I shared my story, people would see that pattern and be more likely to believe me and support me.
Well, what happened is the moderator decided that after I shared the story of two of the priest's other survivors, I had talked too long.
She would not give me the time to share my own story even though I had already recounted my story to her. She knew my story was very appropriate for the forum, but she wasn't going to let me tell it.
She would not give me the time to share my own story even though I had already recounted my story to her. She knew my story was very appropriate for the forum, but she wasn't going to let me tell it.
In addition, when I shared the stories of other survivors during the forum, the Church-contracted moderator allowed other Catholic parishioners to criticize me, put me down, and interrupt me. She sat quietly while they complained that I was telling someone else’s story and that I had no business doing that. They questioned how I knew what I knew.
Well, I knew what I knew by meeting with and listening in person to the other survivors abused by this priest -- something this Church-employed moderator also knew because I had told her about these meetings in private too. But the parishioners didn't know that.
Even though I told these other survivors' stories and not mine, based on my experience of receiving a hostile reaction from other parishioners when I tried to tell my story outside of the forum, I probably would have been put down, criticized, and interrupted by parishioners if I told only my own story, but at least it would have been my own story.
So therapists make mistakes too. My therapist was an ex-Catholic who worked with clergy abuse survivors, but she had never participated in a forum in a Catholic Church on the subject of clergy abuse. She had no way of knowing how the church employed moderator or the other parishioners would act.
I was deeply and profoundly hurt by the harsh attacks and criticisms I received from other parishioners. I felt depressed and hopeless for a few weeks afterward. I had believed in citizens' diplomacy. I thought if only we brought people together to hear each other's stories, they would understand each other. I didn't know that Christians could be so mean-spirited and cruel, so judgmental, and so lacking in compassion.
However, I understood through this experience that if I was deeply hurt by other Catholics, clergy abuse survivors would have been even more deeply wounded. The forum showed me that Catholics needed to be taught to listen with a concern for healing as a partial solution to the clergy abuse issue. This failed forum helped me understand that most ordinary Catholics have no awareness of listening in ways that support healing for clergy abuse survivors as well as the healing of other Catholics.
Or, in other words, Catholics would benefit from taking therapeutic classes to help them know how to interact with wounded clergy abuse survivors AND each other.
However, I understood through this experience that if I was deeply hurt by other Catholics, clergy abuse survivors would have been even more deeply wounded. The forum showed me that Catholics needed to be taught to listen with a concern for healing as a partial solution to the clergy abuse issue. This failed forum helped me understand that most ordinary Catholics have no awareness of listening in ways that support healing for clergy abuse survivors as well as the healing of other Catholics.
Or, in other words, Catholics would benefit from taking therapeutic classes to help them know how to interact with wounded clergy abuse survivors AND each other.
Well, anyway, I felt extremely hurt and angry after that forum during which the Church contracted moderator allowed me to be criticized, interrupted, put down, and ultimately silenced. I decided to express my feelings. I probably should have written a letter about my feelings and never sent it. Writing a letter that I would never send would have been an example of calming down my feelings through journaling. If I was going to send my letter, I probably should have directed all my anger at the moderator of the forum who allowed other Catholics to put me down, criticize me, and silence me. Instead, I directed my anger at the clergy abuse survivor who had helped me start the forum. He hadn’t moderated the forum and was not directly responsible for my rough treatment during the forum.
After receiving a few angry e-mails from me, he sent me a terse reply telling me to never contact him again.
I was aware at the time I wrote the angry e-mails that my therapist would tell me not to actually send them to him, but I sent them anyway because I really wanted him to know how hurt and angry I was.
I apologized to him in several more e-mails. These e-mails led to an e-mail from him threatening to block me if I kept e-mailing him.
Even if he was unable to forgive me, the reality remains that I expressed my anger at him very strongly and very inappropriately in ways I knew a therapist would tell me not to do, and I lost a valuable relationship in the process.
A few years ago, I was in a similar situation, except even more consequential. I was physically and verbally attacked by someone. I reacted to defend myself. I think anyone in a similar situation would find it hard to cope with the extreme anger I was subjected to, but there were several things I could have done to reduce the conflict that I was aware of at the time -- things I knew my therapist would tell me to do -- but once again I did not do them.
So, with three of the greatest regrets of my life, I knew what a therapist would tell me to do, but I did not do it.
Therapists are not always 100% right, but they can help us figure out better ways of coping with bad situations. If we think a therapist is giving us bad advice, we can always go to another therapist. If we try two or three therapists and they all agree, then maybe we are the problem, not the therapist. Even if the therapist is the problem, the best way to discuss the issue with the therapist is the way a therapist would—respectfully.
If you struggle with anger as I have and can't afford a therapist to help you cope, here are two of my blogs about some of the ways I calmed my anger:
If you struggle with anger as I have and can't afford a therapist to help you cope, here are two of my blogs about some of the ways I calmed my anger:
https://compassionategathering.blogspot.com/2026/08/be-on-guard-to-listen-first-or-how-to.html
I also recommend five books to give you tools for healing:
I also recommend five books to give you tools for healing:
Nonviolent Communication: A Language of Life by Marshall Rosenberg, PhD.
The Dialectical Behavior Therapy Skills Workbook: Practical DBT Exercises for Learning Mindfulness, Interpersonal Effectiveness, Emotional Regulation and Distress Tolerance by Matthew McKay, PhD, Jeffrey C. Wood, PSY.D., and Jeffrey Brantley, MD
The Power of Intention: Learning to Co-create Your Way by Dr. Wayne Dyer
For Clergy Abuse: Healing the Sexually Abused Heart: A Workbook for Survivors, Thrivers and Supporters by Dr. Jaime Romo.
© 2015 Virginia Pickles Jones
© 2015 Virginia Pickles Jones
Comments
Post a Comment